Thursday, November 20, 2025

The Benner Cycle

Benner created the chart after studying historical prices for commodities like pig iron, hogs, and corn, using repeating numerical intervals to project market phases forward: 

Samuel Benner’s classic “Periods When to Make Money” chart maps ~150 years of market cycles — flagging when to buy, when to sell, and when to brace for panics.


  • "A" (Panic Years): Marked along the top row (including years like 1927, 1981, 1999, 2019, 2035, and 2053), representing periods of market panic and extreme volatility. 
  • "B" (Good Times / Peaks): Marked along the middle peaks (including 1999, 2007, 2016, 2026, and 2043), described as years of high prices and favorable times to sell stocks and other assets. 
  • "C" (Hard Times / Troughs): Marked along the bottom valleys (including 2012, 2023, 2032, and 2050), described as years of low prices and good times to buy and hold assets until a boom. 

Practical Reality for Investing
  • Historical curiosity, not a timing rule: While the chart periodically goes viral—especially around labeled "B" or "A" years like 2026—rigid calendar-interval charts are not reliable financial forecasting tools. 
  • Market timing risk: Modern market structure, interest rates, earnings, and liquidity differ vastly from 19th-century commodity markets. Trying to buy or sell strictly by fixed cycle years can lead to missed upside or poorly timed exits. 
  • Better decision framework: Base asset allocation, profit-taking, and buying on your time horizon, risk tolerance, diversification, and current valuation/cash-flow fundamentals rather than a fixed cycle chart. 


No comments:

Post a Comment