Benner created the chart after studying historical prices for commodities like pig iron, hogs, and corn, using repeating numerical intervals to project market phases forward:
Samuel Benner’s classic “Periods When to Make Money” chart maps ~150 years of market cycles — flagging when to buy, when to sell, and when to brace for panics.
- "A" (Panic Years): Marked along the top row (including years like 1927, 1981, 1999, 2019, 2035, and 2053), representing periods of market panic and extreme volatility.
- "B" (Good Times / Peaks): Marked along the middle peaks (including 1999, 2007, 2016, 2026, and 2043), described as years of high prices and favorable times to sell stocks and other assets.
- "C" (Hard Times / Troughs): Marked along the bottom valleys (including 2012, 2023, 2032, and 2050), described as years of low prices and good times to buy and hold assets until a boom.
Practical Reality for Investing
- Historical curiosity, not a timing rule: While the chart periodically goes viral—especially around labeled "B" or "A" years like 2026—rigid calendar-interval charts are not reliable financial forecasting tools.
- Market timing risk: Modern market structure, interest rates, earnings, and liquidity differ vastly from 19th-century commodity markets. Trying to buy or sell strictly by fixed cycle years can lead to missed upside or poorly timed exits.
- Better decision framework: Base asset allocation, profit-taking, and buying on your time horizon, risk tolerance, diversification, and current valuation/cash-flow fundamentals rather than a fixed cycle chart.

No comments:
Post a Comment